Fitbit vs Apple Watch: Which one wins?

In the world of wearables, the debate of Apple Watch vs Fitbit has always stood out. Both have a ton of features to help you track your fitness, monitor your health and stay connected.

But which one is for you? In this comparison we’ll go deep into the pros and cons of Fitbit and Apple Watch so you can make an informed decision on your next wearable purchase.

Design and Hardware

Apple Watch: Sleek

The Apple Watch is an icon in the smartwatch world, known for its sleek rectangular design with rounded corners. It comes in aluminum, stainless steel and titanium and looks premium.

The digital crown and side button make navigation easy and the bright and crisp Retina display makes information easy to read even in sunlight.

Fitbit: Options for Every Style

Fitbit has more options than ever, from slim fitness bands like the Charge series to smartwatch style devices like the Versa and Sense. This means you can choose a device that fits your lifestyle and style.

While not as premium looking as the Apple Watch, Fitbit devices often have longer battery life and are generally more affordable.

Fitness and Health Tracking

Apple Watch: Full Health Suite

The Apple Watch is great at health and fitness tracking:

  • Heart rate monitoring

  • ECG (on newer models)

  • Blood oxygen monitoring

  • Fall detection

  • Noise level monitoring

  • Menstrual cycle tracking

  • Sleep tracking

Apple’s Activity Rings make it easy to track daily movement, exercise and standing time. The Workout app supports many activities from running and cycling to swimming and yoga.

Fitbit: Fitness and Sleep Tracking

Fitbit devices are fitness first:

  • Step tracking

  • Heart rate monitoring

  • Sleep tracking

  • Menstrual health tracking

  • Stress tracking (on some models)

  • SpO2 tracking (on some models)

Fitbit’s app gives you detailed insights into your fitness trends, sleep patterns and overall health. Active Zone Minutes encourages you to get your heart rate up throughout the week.

Smart Features and Apps

Apple Watch: A Real Smartwatch

The Apple Watch is a full smartwatch experience:

  • Cellular (on some models)

  • Apple Pay

  • Siri

  • App Store with thousands of third-party apps

  • Make and receive calls and texts

  • Music storage

The tight integration with your iPhone makes the Apple Watch an extension of your phone, with seamless notifications and interactions.

Fitbit: Fitness first with Smart features

While Fitbit devices have become more smart, they’re still fitness trackers first. Depending on the model you may get:

  • Basic phone notifications

  • Fitbit Pay (on some models)

  • Amazon Alexa or Google Assistant (on newer models)

  • Limited third-party app support

  • Music controls and storage (on some models)

The smart features on Fitbit devices are more basic than the Apple Watch but cover the essentials for fitness enthusiasts.

Battery Life

Apple Watch: Daily Charge Required

One of the biggest drawbacks of the Apple Watch is the battery life. Most models need daily charging, especially if you’re using GPS or cellular. You can expect around 18 hours of battery life so nightly charging is usually required.

Fitbit: Long Lasting Power

Fitbit devices have much better battery life. Depending on the model you can expect:

  • 4-7 days for smartwatch style devices like the Versa and Sense

  • Up to 10 days for fitness bands like the Charge series

This longer battery life means less charging and you can use sleep tracking without worrying about running out of power.

Ecosystem and Compatibility

Apple Watch: iOS Only

The Apple Watch is iOS only. This tight integration is great for iOS users but excluded Android users. If you’re already in the Apple ecosystem the Apple Watch offers the best integration with your other Apple devices and services.

Fitbit: Cross Platform

Fitbit devices work with both iOS and Android phones, making them a more flexible option for users who switch between platforms or use Android devices. The Fitbit app is available on both platforms so you get the same experience no matter what phone you use.

Price

Apple Watch Series 8: Premium

Apple Watches are premium priced:

  • Apple Watch SE: $279

  • Apple Watch Series 8: $399

  • Apple Watch Ultra: $799

These prices go up with cellular models, larger sizes or premium materials like stainless steel or titanium.

Fitbit: More Options

Fitbit has more price points:

  • Fitbit Inspire 2: $99.95

  • Fitbit Charge 5: $149.95

  • Fitbit Versa 4: $229.95

  • Fitbit Sense 2: $299.95

You can choose a device that fits your budget and still get good fitness tracking.

Ultimately the choice between a Fitbit and an Apple Watch comes down to you. Here are the key points:

Choose Apple Watch if:

  • You’re an iPhone user and want iOS integration

  • You want a full smartwatch experience

  • You want advanced health features like ECG and fall detection

  • You don’t mind daily charging

  • You’re willing to pay premium

Choose Fitbit if:

  • You want a fitness tracker with some smart features

  • Battery life is your top priority

  • You use Android devices or switch between iOS and Android

  • You want a more affordable option

  • You want more design options

Conclusion

Both Fitbit and Apple Watch are great for health and fitness enthusiasts. The Apple Watch is a full smartwatch with tight iOS integration, Fitbit has longer battery life and fitness tracking at a lower price point.

If you’re an iPhone user and want a do-it-all smartwatch and are willing to pay premium the Apple Watch is hard to beat.

But if you’re primarily a fitness tracker, want longer battery life or use Android devices a Fitbit might be the way to go.

Author

Ed

Full-time writer, Apple fanboy and macOS supremacist. Currently running: 16" Macbook Pro w/ 64GB RAM & M1 Max. Already wants to upgrade to the M3 😫😭

Read more from Ed